Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

I was impressed with his Martinu series on Hyperion.

+ the earlier

http://www.amazon.com/Martinu-cuisine-Christmas-Sinfonietta-ricercari/dp/B00000E4XT

some of CH's baroque & classical period performances could be slightly bland in the Limey tradition but he could 'goose' it up when called for, inspired also. His William Byrd "My Ladye Nevelle's Books" is still valuable also.

The Mozart PC series with Robert Levin is especially fine, hard to believe-- pace another thread-- people still tolerate say the ultra-bland conducting of Murray Perahaia & numerous others compared to later Hogood (he actually got better, or at least more lively, as a conductor) and best German/French +++ "alte" masters.

I generally value CH most in lesser known middle-period Haydn symphonies but I wouldn't have walked outta this early--

Edited by MomsMobley
Posted

FWIW, and IIRC according to bassist Barry Guy, who was in the orchestra, virtually all of Hogwood's Oiseau Lyre recordings were exercises in sight reading, e.g. the Mozart symphonies. Haven't heard all of them, of course, but those I did hear sounded that way to me. I agree with Moms that latter-day German, French (I would add Italian, especially in Vivaldi) "alte musik" ensembles are at their frequent best in another world altogether. Also, for me, in the Mozart symphonies it's such figures as Bohm, Klemperer, and Szell (in their various ways) who bring home the bacon. In particular, what I get from them is a simultaneous grasp of the music's horizontal and vertical factors.

Posted

FWIW, and IIRC according to bassist Barry Guy, who was in the orchestra, virtually all of Hogwood's Oiseau Lyre recordings were exercises in sight reading, e.g. the Mozart symphonies. Haven't heard all of them, of course, but those I did hear sounded that way to me. I agree with Moms that latter-day German, French (I would add Italian, especially in Vivaldi) "alte musik" ensembles are at their frequent best in another world altogether. Also, for me, in the Mozart symphonies it's such figures as Bohm, Klemperer, and Szell (in their various ways) who bring home the bacon. In particular, what I get from them is a simultaneous grasp of the music's horizontal and vertical factors.

Definitely LK. The Hogwood Beethoven sounds nice and is mostly quiet good but... not quite good enough compared to best HIP or modern/HIP hybirds like Emmanuel Krivine. The Mozart & Vivaldi, most of the Handel & Bach etc... is "interesting" for the time but I don't think there's any question 1) Hogwood got better and 2) the whole movement got A LOT better.

It's a fair argument too who was "better," Hogwood or Neville Marriner, say, with ASMF but unless your English and have a lot invested in a vinyl classical collection, it's a fool's game to sort it out when dozens upon dozens of fantastic French/Italian/German groups have revivified SOUND and performance practice so brilliantly. (Plus some of Hogwood's singers in Handel, Haydn are tough to take; he's FAR from alone in that-- it ruined a generation of UK and US sourced baroque recordings but...)

some lesser known top notch Hogwood is his Gade series on Chandos btw; not saying everyone "needs" the music but if interests lead one to the period/place...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jkDxfLH84mY

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...