A Lark Ascending Posted November 1, 2003 Report Posted November 1, 2003 (edited) The John McLaughlin Montreux Concerts 1974-2003 - 17-CD set (Warner Bros) Too much of a good thing? Disc: 1 1. Power Of Love 2. Wings Of Karma 3. Smile Of The Beyond Disc: 2 1. Vision Is A Naked Sword 2. Hymn To Him 3. Sanctuary Disc: 3 1. Joy 2. India Disc: 4 1. Nata 2. Kriti Disc: 5 1. La Danse Du Bonheur 2. India 3. Get Down And Sruti 4. Joy Disc: 6 1. Meeting Of The Spirits 2. Friendship 3. Two Sisters 4. Mind Ecology & Do You Hear The Voices We Left Behind 5. Phenomenon Compulsion & Hope Disc: 7 1. La Baleine 2. Waltze 3. Romance 4. Sketches 5. Turn Around 6. Thelonius Melodius 7. Beautiful Love (dedicated to Bill Evans) Disc: 8 1. Radio Activity 2. Nostalgia 3. East Side West Side 4. Clarendon Hills 5. (1) Blues for L.W., (2) It's The Pits & (3) Living On The Crest Of A Wave Disc: 9 1. Jozy 2. Pacific Express 3. Mitch Match 4. Mitch Match (reprise) Disc: 10 1. (1) One Melody & (2) My Foolish Heart 2. El Panuelo 3. Spain 4. Chiquito 5. Florianapolis Disc: 11 1. Frevo 2. David 3. Sichia 4. Guardian Angels Disc: 12 1. Thelonius Melodius 2. Matinale 3. When Love Is Far Away 4. Nostalgia 5. Mother Tongues 6. 1 Nite Stand Disc: 13 1. Tones For Elvin Jones 2. Matinale 3. Sing Me Softly Of The Blues 4. The Man Will Fall Disc: 14 1. After The Rain 2. Mother Tongues 3. Old Folks Disc: 15 1. Seven Sisters 2. Social Climate 3. Mr. D.C. 4. Tony 5. Acid Jazz 6. Jazz Jungle Disc: 16 1. 5 In The Morning, 6 In The Afternoon 2. Ma No Pa 3. Anna 4. Finding The Way 5. La Danse Du Bonheur Disc: 17 1. Canto de Xango (Bonus Disc) 2. Frevo (Bonus Disc) Details: http://jazzmatazz.home.att.net/ Release date would appear to be Nov 17th in UK, Feb 2004 in US. Edited November 1, 2003 by Bev Stapleton Quote
Joe G Posted November 1, 2003 Report Posted November 1, 2003 Jesus! I think you may be right. Even half that many discs would give me pause... Quote
Michael Fitzgerald Posted November 1, 2003 Report Posted November 1, 2003 Sounds great to me! Thing about this is that there is a huge amount of variety - if someone tried to push a 17 CD set by the Modern Jazz Quartet from their final 25 years, I'd definitely balk. This has Mahavishnu (lineup with JL Ponty), Shakti (a few different versions, old and new), the One Truth band, a duo set with Chick Corea, the Mahavisnu band with Bill Evans and Mitch Forman (and NO drummer? No Cobham? No Gottlieb?), a duo set with Paco De Lucia (and NO Al DiMeola, thank God), two shows by the organ trio with DeFrancesco, a set by the "Heart of Things" band Apparently someone put the kibosh on the 1972 Mahavishnu Orchestra (original lineup). www.montreuxsounds.ch has all the details. I wish there were a couple of other bands - the one with Katia Labeque, the trio with Trilok Gurtu, etc. but this is still a phenomenal addition to the available McLaughlin discography. And it's legit! Sir, may I have some more? Mike Quote
king ubu Posted November 3, 2003 Report Posted November 3, 2003 MAHAVISHNU ORCHESTRA (CDs 1-2) Jul 7, 1974 Congrés Montreux John McLaughlin (g) Jean-Luc Ponty (vln) Gayle Moran (org-voc) Ralph Armstrong (B) Michael Walden (dr) Steve Kindlter (vln) Carol Shive (vln) Marsha Westbrook (alto) Phil Hirschi (cello) Bob Knapp (tp, cor) Steve Frankivitch (tp, cor) SHAKTI (CDs 3-4) Jul 6, 1976 Casino John McLaughlin (g) L. Shankar (vln) T.H. Vinayakram (ghatam, mridangam) Zajir Hussain (tabla) 1. Joy (13:28) 2. India (22:08) 3. Nata (33:52) 4. Kriti (15:00) SHAKTI (CD 5) Jul 8, 1977 Casino John McLaughlin (g) L. Shankar (vln) R.-H. Vinayakram (ghatam, mridangam) Zakir Hussain (tabla) 1. La Danse Du Bonheur (14:55) 2. India (16:33) 3. Get Down In Shuti (35:23) 4. Joy (08:33) JOHN MCLAUGHLIN BAND (CD 6) Jul 19, 1978 Casino John McLaughlin (g) L. Shankar (vln) Stu Goldberg (kbds) W. "Sonship" Theus (dr) Tom Stevens (B) 1. Meeting Of The Spirits (16:42) 2. Friendship (intro 5'15) (11:59) 3. Two Sisters (05:41) 4. The Voices We Left Behind (21:07) 5. Do You Remember (06:40) 6. Mind Ecology (07:55) CHICK COREA & JOHN MCLAUGHLIN (CD 7) Jul 15, 1981 Casino Chick Corea (p) John McLaughlin (g) 1. La Baleina (08:20) 2. Waltze (08:41) 3. Romance (10:22) 4. Sketches (08:59) 5. Turn Around (10:38) 6. Thelonious Melodius (08:44) 7. Beautiful Love (06:01) MAHAVISHNU ORCHESTRA (CDs 8-9) Jul 18, 1984 Casino John McLaughlin (g) Bill Evans (s) Mitchell Forman (kbds) Jonas Hellborg (B) 1. Radio Activity (09:45) 2. Nostalgia (10:50) 3. East Side, West Side (14:18) 4. Clarendin Hills (09:50) 5. Solo Bass : It's The Pits & Living On The Crest Of A Wave (13:30) 6. Just Ideas (00:00) 7. Jozy (13:20) 8. Pacific Express (21:05) 9. Mitch Match (12:38) JOHN MCLAUGHLIN & PACO DE LUCIA (CDs 10-11) Jul 15, 1987 Casino John McLaughlin (g) Paco De Lucia (g) 1. One Melody (09:02) 2. El Panuelo (06:13) 3. Spain (10:52) 4. Chiquito (08:46) 5. Florianapolis (11:26) 6. Frevo (07:36) 7. David (10:56) 8. Sichia (07:00) 9. Guardian Angel (06:19) JOHN MCLAUGHLIN WITH THE FREE SPIRITS (CD 12) Jul 4, 1993 Stravinski John McLaughlin (g) Dennis Chambers (dr) Joey Di Francesco (org) 1. Are You The One (06:48) 2. ...in Ale (16:15) 3. When Love Is Far Away (05:22) 4. Nostalgia (05:29) 5. Mother Tongues (13:45) 6. One Nite Stand (04:16) JOHN MCLAUGHLIN & THE FREE SPIRITS (CDs 13-14) Jul 18, 1995 Stravinski John McLaughlin (g) Dennis Chambers (dr) Joey De Francesco (org, tp) 1. Tones For Elvin Jones (09:15) 2. Matinale (20:11) 3. Sing Me Softly Of The Blues (07:52) 4. The Man Was FAll (14:16) 5 . After The Rain (05:54) 6. Mother Tongues (20:13) 7. Old Folks (06:01) JOHN MCLAUGHLIN & "THE HEART OF THINGS" (CD 15) Jul 11, 1998 Stravinski JOHN McLAUGHLIN (guit.) JIM BEARD (kbds.) GARY THOMAS (sax, flute) MATTHEW GARRISON (bass) DENNIS CHAMBERS (dr.) 1. SEVEN SISTERS (13:53) 2. SOCIAL CLIMAT (08:45) 3. MISTER D.C. (12:53) 4. TONY (07:20) 5. ACID JAZZ (12:49) 6. JAZZ JUNGLE (08:58) JOHN MCLAUGHLIN (CD 16) Jul 8, 1999 MDH JOHN MC LAUGHLIN (guit.) ZAKIR HUSSAIN (tabla) UPPALAPU SHRINIVAS (mandolin) V. SELVAGANESH (indian perc.) 1. FIVE IN THE MORNING, SIX IN THE AFTERNOON (16:36) 2. MA NO PA (13:52) 3. ANNA (14:28) 4. FINDING THE WAY (20:04) 5. LA DANSE DU BONHEUR (03:50) Don't know where this one could fit in: SHAKTI Jul 18, 2001 Stravinski John McLaughlin (guitare) Zakir Hussain (tabla) Vinayakram Selvagtanesh (ghatam, kanjira, maretangham) Mandolin Shrinivas (mandolin) Bhavani Shankar (perc) Debashish Bhattacharya (guitare) Shankar Mahadevan (voc) 1. Finding the way (19:21) 2. Giriraj Sudha (10:14) 3. Shringar (13:00) 4. Manopa (18:23) 5. Niyati (16:58) and this would have been the 1972 Mahavishnu concert: MAHAVISHNU ORCHESTRA Aug 20, 1972 Montreux Pavillon John McLaughlin (guitares) Jerry Goddman (violon) Jan Hammer (piano / moog) Rick Laird (basse) Billy Cobham (batterie) 1. Meetings Of The Spirits (00:00) . You Know, You Know (28:45) 2. Dance Of The Mayas (15:15) 3. One Word (10:40) 4. Lotus On Irish Streams (09:20) 5. Noonward Race (23:00) 6. Binky's Bean (04:30) (ALL INFORMATION TAKEN FROM THE SITE MIKE MENTIONED ABOVE) ubu Quote
Joe G Posted November 3, 2003 Report Posted November 3, 2003 Okay, I have to admit; that's pretty damn impressive! Quote
king ubu Posted November 3, 2003 Report Posted November 3, 2003 Okay, I have to admit; that's pretty damn impressive! Indeed! Seems like I won't get no food in november... Quote
7/4 Posted November 3, 2003 Report Posted November 3, 2003 Yikes! I don't know if I can handle this...... Quote
A Lark Ascending Posted November 3, 2003 Author Report Posted November 3, 2003 (edited) Got to admire the variety. Very tempting. Maybe the record company could offer a free set to the person who guesses how many notes he plays over the entire 17 discs. Edited November 3, 2003 by Bev Stapleton Quote
Claude Posted November 3, 2003 Report Posted November 3, 2003 The format of this interesting project is as ridiculous as the Miles@Montreux set. I would buy 2 or 3 of the concerts if they were available seperately, but 17CDs - no way. Miles Davis - Complete Montreux (20CD box) - Does it sell? Quote
Bright Moments Posted July 12, 2008 Report Posted July 12, 2008 carpe diem - if you are into this: http://cgi.ebay.com/John-McLaughlin-Shakti...0QQcmdZViewItem Quote
Van Basten II Posted December 11, 2009 Report Posted December 11, 2009 (edited) Found one at the used cd store for 180 $. Deal or no deal ? Edited December 11, 2009 by Van Basten II Quote
jazzbo Posted December 11, 2009 Report Posted December 11, 2009 Seems like a deal to me. I'd bite in your shoes. Would be a lot of music! I may not like all of it but I bet I like quite a bit. Quote
sal Posted December 11, 2009 Report Posted December 11, 2009 I bought this box set for my dad about 5 years ago for his birthday. I gave the whole set a listen at one point over a weekend, and I remember really liking the majority of it. The only stuff I didn't care for was the 1980's version of the Mahavishnu Orchestra, but it was easily overshadowed by all the other great stuff in the set. The Shakti stuff, the duo sets, and the band with Joey DeFrancesco are the ones I remember as being particularly impressive. Quote
7/4 Posted December 11, 2009 Report Posted December 11, 2009 I never did buy it. I'd love to own it. The '70s recordings still rock me. Quote
Van Basten II Posted December 12, 2009 Report Posted December 12, 2009 Asked the lady at the store to put it with my pile of stuff to buy later, should pick it up next week near the holidays, guess it will be a Mclaughlin Christmas for yours truly. Quote
mjzee Posted December 12, 2009 Report Posted December 12, 2009 Amazon UK currently has new copies of this for £121.98 - converted, about $198. Quote
Shrdlu Posted December 12, 2009 Report Posted December 12, 2009 I'm surprised that there are so many disks in this set. For a long time, I've felt that John was under-recorded. All I have thus far are the sessions with Miles (on which he just about steals the show) and a copy of "The Heart of Things" that I obtained from a Swiss-German satellite TV station - they used to play CDs on air after broadcasting was over for the night. Quote
king ubu Posted December 14, 2009 Report Posted December 14, 2009 You ought to check out the early releases of the Mahavishnu Orchestra! Urgently! Quote
mjzee Posted December 14, 2009 Report Posted December 14, 2009 Yes, the original Mahavishnu Orchestra were just amazing. If there were still an American record industry, they would deserve a boxed set retrospective, remastered, with unissued tracks and a booklet - like a Rhino deluxe package. Quote
king ubu Posted December 16, 2009 Report Posted December 16, 2009 Yes, the original Mahavishnu Orchestra were just amazing. If there were still an American record industry, they would deserve a boxed set retrospective, remastered, with unissued tracks and a booklet - like a Rhino deluxe package. I'd be all over that! I only have the first two and the "Lost Trident" (which indeed is not the great relevation some had hoped it would be). I think there's be one more album to have, but that one only came out in an old stinkin' version, right? (I'm thinking of "Between Nothingness and Eternity") Quote
mjzee Posted December 16, 2009 Report Posted December 16, 2009 Yes, the original Mahavishnu Orchestra were just amazing. If there were still an American record industry, they would deserve a boxed set retrospective, remastered, with unissued tracks and a booklet - like a Rhino deluxe package. I'd be all over that! I only have the first two and the "Lost Trident" (which indeed is not the great relevation some had hoped it would be). I think there's be one more album to have, but that one only came out in an old stinkin' version, right? (I'm thinking of "Between Nothingness and Eternity") BNAE is an AMAZING album. You have to have it (and I don't say that often here). I think it's head and shoulders above Inner Mounting Flame and Birds Of Fire. It rocks, it thunders. I was at one of those concerts that weekend (including the one that produced "Dream" for the album), and I can attest that's what they sounded like live. They rock! Check out McLaughlin's breaking into "Sunshine of Your Love" during "Dream." I would love to have an expanded version of this album. I think "Lost Trident" is just the studio version of the material that went into BNAE; it was probably nixed because they thought the live versions were superior. Quote
king ubu Posted December 16, 2009 Report Posted December 16, 2009 Yes, the original Mahavishnu Orchestra were just amazing. If there were still an American record industry, they would deserve a boxed set retrospective, remastered, with unissued tracks and a booklet - like a Rhino deluxe package. I'd be all over that! I only have the first two and the "Lost Trident" (which indeed is not the great relevation some had hoped it would be). I think there's be one more album to have, but that one only came out in an old stinkin' version, right? (I'm thinking of "Between Nothingness and Eternity") BNAE is an AMAZING album. You have to have it (and I don't say that often here). I think it's head and shoulders above Inner Mounting Flame and Birds Of Fire. It rocks, it thunders. I was at one of those concerts that weekend (including the one that produced "Dream" for the album), and I can attest that's what they sounded like live. They rock! Check out McLaughlin's breaking into "Sunshine of Your Love" during "Dream." I would love to have an expanded version of this album. I think "Lost Trident" is just the studio version of the material that went into BNAE; it was probably nixed because they thought the live versions were superior. That's quite a... well, blazing... recommendation! I'll look for it! Quote
7/4 Posted December 16, 2009 Report Posted December 16, 2009 BNAE is an AMAZING album. You have to have it (and I don't say that often here). I think it's head and shoulders above Inner Mounting Flame and Birds Of Fire. It rocks, it thunders. I was at one of those concerts that weekend (including the one that produced "Dream" for the album), and I can attest that's what they sounded like live. They rock! Check out McLaughlin's breaking into "Sunshine of Your Love" during "Dream." I would love to have an expanded version of this album. I think "Lost Trident" is just the studio version of the material that went into BNAE; it was probably nixed because they thought the live versions were superior. Yes to all the above, that's what I always thought. Quote
jazzbo Posted December 16, 2009 Report Posted December 16, 2009 If I could only have one Mahavishnu Orchestra disc, it would be "Between Nothingness and Eternity." Quote
mjzee Posted December 17, 2009 Report Posted December 17, 2009 If you want to check the album out on the cheap, Amazon has the mp3 version for $2.99. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.