Jump to content

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 61
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted

I have and enjoyed it a lot. Others may disagree, but I found it informative. Nice discussion of Andrew Hill, which is the only one that I am aware of in a book.

Posted (edited)

I agree with both Ronald and Allen :)

It is very well written, and has brief yet interesting discussions.

The errors are annoying though - Lee Morgan died in February '72, not January, and he mispells Frank Wolff throughout.

Bertrand.

Edited by bertrand
Posted

A great primer, though, yes, there are some factual errors--but let's not be too hard on the guy as the MS was published posthumously. A few omissions are odd (Hank Mobley & Grant Green) but by & large it's a very good introduction to the music with an informed list of recommended recordings at the back.

Posted

I haven't read in a decade or more, but it's nice to know that this is back in print. By general recollection, I agree with previous comments: flawed, but better trhan nothing (and, particularly, better than anything else available at time of original publication).

Posted

Bought it, skimmed it a few times, saw nothing particularly compelling and/or informative, and place it on the bottom of the "to get to later" pile.

It's still there.

Posted

I read the library's copy when I was just getting started with jazz; it helped fan the flame, so I can't complain. In all honesty, though, sometimes reading a book about jazz seems to be a lot like singing a song about e. e. cummings. It's interesting that you can do such a thing, but...

Posted

I picked it up in the store, scanned it, put it back.

I did steps 1 & 2 , but bought it.

Then again, it was in a remainder bin for under $5, I'd already had lunch.

Posted

In all honesty, though, sometimes reading a book about jazz seems to be a lot like singing a song about e. e. cummings.

Dancing about architecture?

Posted

IMHO its an excellent book. It introduced me to artists I had barely heard of and has an excellent section on Tina Brooks. I was also impressed by his assessment of the importance of heroin and its relevance to need of black artists to "distance" themselves. Its a book I go back to. Well worth restrieving from the remainder bin.

Posted

In all honesty, though, sometimes reading a book about jazz seems to be a lot like singing a song about e. e. cummings.

Dancing about architecture?

If I could put a stake through that quote's heart (& also Zappa's "smells funny" quote) I would.

If anyone has a spare copy of the Rosenthal they'd like to dispose of tell me as my sister's looking for it & it's o/p.

Posted

If anyone has a spare copy of the Rosenthal they'd like to dispose of tell me as my sister's looking for it & it's o/p.

Copies are available at half.com & amazon.

Lowest price seems to be around $8 + shipping.

Posted (edited)

saw it. bought it. took it to dinner. bought it flowers. took it home. married it. had children with it. divorced it. now only visit it on weekends.

Edited by AllenLowe
Posted

Rosenthal's book is much better than the two you bought, hardbopjazz.

Bertrand.

I agree, if the Rosenthal's a so-so, those two books are a no-no in my opinion.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...